Best Moving Companies Compared
Moving to a new home ranks among life’s most stressful events, but choosing the right moving company can make all the difference between a nightmare and a smooth transition. With hundreds of moving companies operating nationwide, each offering different services, pricing structures, and levels of reliability, finding the best fit for your specific needs requires careful research and comparison.
This comprehensive guide compares the top-rated moving companies in the industry, analyzing their services, pricing models, coverage areas, and customer satisfaction ratings. Whether you’re planning a local move across town or a cross-country relocation, understanding the strengths and limitations of each major provider will help you make an informed decision that protects both your belongings and your budget.
Our analysis focuses on the most reputable national moving companies that consistently receive high customer ratings and maintain proper licensing and insurance coverage. These include industry leaders known for their extensive networks, specialized services, and proven track records in handling everything from studio apartments to large family homes.
Quick Comparison Overview
United Van Lines – Best Overall
- Best For: Long-distance and international moves
- Strengths: Comprehensive services, extensive network, strong reputation
- Coverage: All 50 states and international destinations
- Special Services: Storage solutions, specialty item handling, corporate relocations
Allied Van Lines – Best for Full-Service Moves
- Best For: Customers wanting comprehensive moving assistance
- Strengths: White-glove service, experienced crews, flexible scheduling
- Coverage: Nationwide and international
- Special Services: Packing/unpacking, furniture assembly, custom crating
North American Van Lines – Best Technology Integration
- Best For: Tech-savvy customers who want real-time tracking
- Strengths: Advanced tracking systems, digital inventory management
- Coverage: All 50 states and Canada
- Special Services: Move coordination apps, virtual surveys, GPS tracking
Mayflower – Best Customer Service
- Best For: First-time movers needing guidance and support
- Strengths: Dedicated move coordinators, extensive customer support
- Coverage: Nationwide and international
- Special Services: Moving concierge, settling-in services, pet relocation
Atlas Van Lines – Best for Military Moves
- Best For: Military families and government employees
- Strengths: Military moving expertise, government contracts, specialized training
- Coverage: Nationwide and overseas military bases
- Special Services: Military discounts, storage solutions, government relocations
Two Men and a Truck – Best for Local Moves
- Best For: Local and regional relocations
- Strengths: Affordable pricing, community focus, flexible services
- Coverage: Local and regional (varies by franchise location)
- Special Services: Junk removal, packing supplies, senior moving services
Detailed Comparison
United Van Lines
United Van Lines stands as one of America’s largest and most established moving companies, with nearly a century of experience in the industry. Their extensive network of agents across all 50 states enables them to handle moves of virtually any size and distance, from local relocations to international transfers.
The company excels in providing comprehensive moving solutions that go beyond simple transportation. Their services include professional packing and unpacking, custom crating for valuable items, temporary and long-term storage options, and specialized handling for items like pianos, artwork, and antiques. United Van Lines also maintains strong relationships with corporate clients, making them an excellent choice for company-sponsored relocations.
Their quality assurance program includes background-checked employees, comprehensive insurance coverage options, and a network of certified agents who must meet strict performance standards. The company’s size and resources allow them to handle complex moves that smaller companies might struggle with, including time-sensitive relocations and moves requiring special equipment.
Allied Van Lines
Allied Van Lines has built its reputation on delivering full-service moving experiences with an emphasis on customer care and attention to detail. Their “white-glove” approach means customers can expect comprehensive assistance throughout every phase of their move, from initial planning to final setup in their new home.
The company’s strength lies in its highly trained moving crews and comprehensive service offerings. Allied provides detailed pre-move consultations, professional packing services using high-quality materials, careful handling of specialty items, and post-move services like furniture assembly and debris removal. Their agents undergo extensive training in proper packing techniques, safe loading procedures, and customer service protocols.
Allied Van Lines particularly excels in handling delicate and valuable items, offering custom crating services for artwork, antiques, and fragile collectibles. Their network includes specialists in piano moving, fine art handling, and other specialized transportation needs. The company also provides flexible storage solutions for customers who need temporary housing for their belongings during the moving process.
North American Van Lines
North American Van Lines distinguishes itself through innovative use of technology to enhance the moving experience. Their digital-first approach includes comprehensive online tools for inventory management, real-time shipment tracking, and streamlined communication between customers and their moving teams.
The company’s move coordination platform allows customers to manage their entire relocation online, from obtaining estimates to tracking their shipment’s progress. Their GPS tracking system provides real-time updates on shipment location, while digital inventory systems create detailed records of all items being moved. This technological integration reduces the likelihood of lost items and provides customers with unprecedented visibility into their move’s progress.
North American Van Lines also offers virtual survey options, allowing customers to receive accurate moving estimates without requiring in-home visits. Their mobile apps provide convenient access to all moving information, including delivery windows, contact information for moving crews, and digital copies of all moving documents.
Mayflower
Mayflower has earned recognition for exceptional customer service and comprehensive support throughout the moving process. Their approach emphasizes personal attention and guidance, making them particularly appealing to customers who are moving for the first time or those who prefer hands-on assistance.
Each Mayflower customer receives a dedicated move coordinator who serves as their primary point of contact throughout the entire process. These coordinators help with planning, scheduling, and resolving any issues that may arise during the move. The company’s customer service team receives extensive training in problem resolution and maintains high standards for responsiveness and professionalism.
Mayflower’s services extend beyond traditional moving to include settling-in assistance, helping customers establish utility services, find local service providers, and navigate their new communities. They also offer specialized services for unique moving situations, including pet relocation assistance and coordination with real estate professionals.
Atlas Van Lines
Atlas Van Lines has developed particular expertise in military and government relocations, earning numerous contracts and certifications that demonstrate their capability in handling these specialized moves. Their experience with military families gives them unique insights into the challenges of frequent relocations and the need for reliable, efficient service.
The company offers special pricing and services for military personnel, including flexible scheduling to accommodate deployment timelines and extended storage options for overseas assignments. Their crews receive specialized training in military moving regulations and requirements, ensuring compliance with all relevant policies and procedures.
Atlas Van Lines also maintains strong capabilities in corporate relocations and standard residential moves. Their network includes agents experienced in handling international moves, temporary relocations, and complex logistics situations that require careful coordination and timing.
Two Men and a Truck
Two Men and a Truck operates on a franchise model that emphasizes local community connections and personalized service. While they may not have the extensive resources of the largest national carriers, their local focus often translates into more competitive pricing and greater flexibility for regional and local moves.
The company’s franchised structure allows individual locations to tailor their services to local market needs while maintaining consistent quality standards across the network. Many franchise locations offer additional services beyond moving, including junk removal, packing supply sales, and storage solutions.
Two Men and a Truck has developed particular expertise in serving seniors and customers with special needs, offering patient, careful service that accommodates the unique requirements of these populations. Their local presence also makes them well-suited for last-minute moves or situations requiring quick response times.
Pricing Overview
Moving company pricing varies significantly based on multiple factors, making it essential to understand the key elements that influence costs. Distance represents the primary pricing factor, with local moves typically charged by the hour and long-distance moves priced based on weight and mileage.
Local moves generally range from moderate hourly rates for basic service to higher rates for full-service options. Factors affecting local move pricing include the number of movers required, time of year, day of the week, and additional services like packing or storage.
Long-distance moves follow more complex pricing structures based on shipment weight, distance traveled, and service level selected. Additional factors include fuel costs, tolls, and any special handling requirements for fragile or oversized items.
Service level significantly impacts pricing: Basic loading and transportation services cost substantially less than full-service options that include packing, unpacking, furniture assembly, and other conveniences. Premium services like custom crating, piano moving, or expedited delivery add to the overall cost.
Seasonal pricing fluctuations affect all moving companies, with summer months typically commanding higher rates due to increased demand. Moving during off-peak times or mid-month dates often results in better pricing and more flexible scheduling options.
Insurance coverage options range from basic liability coverage included in standard pricing to comprehensive full-value protection that significantly increases costs but provides complete coverage for damaged or lost items.
Pros and Cons
United Van Lines
Pros:
- Extensive nationwide network ensures coverage everywhere
- Comprehensive service offerings handle any moving need
- Strong reputation and financial stability provide confidence
- Excellent for complex or international moves
Cons:
- Premium pricing may exceed budget-conscious customers’ limits
- Large corporate structure can feel impersonal
- Busy periods may result in less flexible scheduling
Allied Van Lines
Pros:
- Exceptional full-service offerings provide complete convenience
- Highly trained crews deliver professional service
- Strong focus on customer satisfaction and quality control
- Excellent handling of valuable and fragile items
Cons:
- Premium services command higher prices
- May be overkill for simple, straightforward moves
- Limited budget-friendly options for cost-conscious customers
North American Van Lines
Pros:
- Advanced technology provides superior tracking and communication
- Digital tools streamline the moving process
- Virtual surveys offer convenience and accuracy
- Strong reliability and scheduling adherence
Cons:
- Technology focus may not appeal to all customers
- Premium for advanced services
- Less personal touch compared to smaller companies
Mayflower
Pros:
- Outstanding customer service and support
- Dedicated coordinators provide personalized attention
- Comprehensive settling-in services ease transition
- Strong problem resolution capabilities
Cons:
- Higher costs for premium service level
- May be unnecessary for experienced movers
- Limited budget options for basic moves
Atlas Van Lines
Pros:
- Exceptional military and government moving expertise
- Competitive pricing for qualified customers
- Flexible scheduling for unique situations
- Strong reliability and punctuality record
Cons:
- Best benefits limited to military customers
- Smaller network than some competitors
- Fewer premium service options
Two Men and a Truck
Pros:
- Competitive pricing for local and regional moves
- Strong community connections and local knowledge
- Flexible, personalized service approach
- Good value for straightforward relocations
Cons:
- Limited long-distance capabilities
- Inconsistent service quality across franchises
- Fewer premium service options
- May lack resources for complex moves
How to Choose
Selecting the right moving company requires careful consideration of your specific needs, budget, and priorities. Begin by determining your move type and distance, as this immediately narrows your options to companies that specialize in your situation.
Evaluate your service needs honestly. Customers comfortable with packing their own belongings and handling setup tasks can save significantly by choosing basic transportation services. Those preferring comprehensive assistance should focus on full-service providers despite higher costs.
Consider your timeline and flexibility. Customers with rigid scheduling requirements need companies with strong reliability records and extensive networks. Those with flexible timing can often secure better pricing and service by avoiding peak periods.
Assess your risk tolerance and insurance needs. Customers with valuable or irreplaceable items should prioritize companies offering comprehensive coverage options and specialized handling services. Those with standard household goods may find basic coverage adequate.
Research company reputation and credentials. Verify proper licensing, insurance coverage, and Better Business Bureau ratings. Read recent customer reviews focusing on experiences similar to your planned move.
Obtain multiple detailed estimates from at least three companies, ensuring all provide similar service levels for accurate comparison. Be wary of estimates significantly higher or lower than others, as these may indicate hidden costs or service limitations.
Ask specific questions about crew training, equipment quality, damage policies, and problem resolution procedures. Companies confident in their services will provide detailed, transparent answers.
How to Switch/Get Started
Beginning your search for moving companies should start 6-8 weeks before your planned move date to ensure adequate time for research, booking, and preparation. Peak moving seasons require even earlier planning to secure preferred dates and avoid premium pricing.
Start with research and credential verification. Check company licensing through the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration database and verify insurance coverage. Read recent customer reviews and check Better Business Bureau ratings to identify potential issues.
Contact multiple companies for estimates, providing identical information to ensure accurate comparisons. In-home surveys typically provide more accurate estimates than phone or online quotes, particularly for larger moves or those including specialty items.
Compare estimates carefully, looking beyond total cost to understand what services are included. Ask about additional fees, insurance options, and policies regarding delays or changes to your moving plan.
Book your chosen company as soon as possible after making your decision, as popular movers fill their schedules quickly during busy periods. Confirm all details in writing, including dates, services, pricing, and insurance coverage.
Begin preparation immediately by decluttering possessions, gathering important documents, and coordinating utility disconnections and connections. Companies offering packing services typically schedule these 1-2 days before loading.
Maintain communication with your moving coordinator as your date approaches, confirming details and addressing any changes to your situation. Prepare for moving day by ensuring clear access to your home, having payment ready, and conducting thorough walkthroughs before and after loading.
FAQ
Q: What’s the difference between binding and non-binding estimates?
Binding estimates guarantee the total cost won’t exceed the quoted amount, provided your inventory remains unchanged. Non-binding estimates provide cost projections but allow for adjustments based on actual weight and services required. Binding estimates offer more predictability but may cost slightly more upfront.
Q: How do full-service movers compare to self-service options?
Full-service movers handle everything from packing to unpacking, providing maximum convenience but at premium pricing. Self-service options require you to handle packing and unpacking while the company provides transportation, offering significant cost savings for those willing to do more work themselves.
Q: Which moving companies offer the best insurance coverage?
Most reputable movers offer both basic liability coverage (included in base pricing) and full-value protection (additional cost). United Van Lines, Allied, and Mayflower typically provide the most comprehensive coverage options, while smaller companies may have more limited insurance choices.
Q: How do local moving companies compare to national chains?
National chains offer extensive networks, standardized service quality, and resources for complex moves, but often at higher costs. Local companies may provide more personalized service and competitive pricing for regional moves, but may lack resources for long-distance or specialized relocations.
Q: What should I expect from premium moving services vs. basic options?
Premium services include professional packing/unpacking, furniture disassembly/assembly, custom crating, and white-glove handling, providing maximum convenience and protection. Basic services focus on loading, transportation, and unloading, requiring more customer involvement but offering significant cost savings.
Q: How do military moving specialists compare to standard moving companies?
Military specialists like Atlas Van Lines understand unique military requirements, offer specialized pricing and services, and have experience with frequent relocations and overseas moves. Standard movers may offer better pricing for non-military customers but lack specialized military moving expertise and benefits.
Conclusion
Choosing the right moving company significantly impacts both your moving experience and your budget. The best option depends on your specific needs, timeline, and priorities rather than a one-size-fits-all solution. United Van Lines and Allied Van Lines excel for comprehensive, full-service relocations, while North American Van Lines leads in technology integration. Mayflower provides exceptional customer service, Atlas Van Lines specializes in military moves, and Two Men and a Truck offers value for local relocations.
Success in finding the right moving company requires careful research, multiple estimates, and honest assessment of your needs and budget. Don’t rush this important decision – the time invested in proper comparison shopping pays dividends in reduced stress and better outcomes.
Ready to find the perfect moving company for your relocation? YouCompare.com makes it easy to compare top-rated moving companies side-by-side, helping you find the best value for your specific needs. Our independent comparison tools provide unbiased reviews, detailed service comparisons, and insights from thousands of customers who’ve made successful moves. Visit YouCompare.com today to access our comprehensive moving company comparison tools and make a smarter choice for your next move. With our commitment to helping consumers find better deals and make informed decisions, you can move forward with confidence knowing you’ve chosen the right partner for your relocation.
